|
Benchmarks
The SB51G offers decent performance in a small physical form factor.
Though it uses an older generation chipset and processor, the SB51G
is still no slouch when it comes to most real world applications. If
you want to squeeze out even more performance from the SB51G, install
an AGP graphics card and a dedicated sound card.
For benchmarks, we compared the SB51G against a
number of differnet types of systems. A few of our benchmarks were recently
introduced at WhiningDog and thus we still have few data points to use.
Because of this, we used a wide variety of systems depending on the benchmark.
Always take benchmarks with a grain of salt. Use them for what they are
- a relative comparison between different systems.
Here are the various Pentium 4 systems compared
against:
| Component |
Shuttle SB51G |
Abit BG7E |
MiniQ |
| Processor |
Pentium 4 2.4B 533 |
Pentium 4 2.4B 533 |
Pentium 4 2.4B 533 |
| Memory |
512MB Crucial DDR333 |
256MB Crucial DDR333 |
256 MB Crucial DDR 266 |
| DVD Drive |
Lite-On DVD ROM |
Toshiba DVD-ROM |
Toshiba DVD-ROM |
| Hard Drive |
Maxtor 120GB 7200 RPM |
Maxtor 60GB 7200 RPM |
Maxtor 60GB 7200 RPM |
| Chipset |
Intel 845GE/ICH4 |
Intel 845GE/ICH4 |
SiS 651 + 962 |
| Graphics |
On board |
On board |
On board |
We also compared the SB51G against dual processor
XEON systems. The specs for the XEON systems are as follows:
| Component |
Supermicro X5DAE |
Supermicro X5DAL-TG2 |
Iwill DP533 |
| Processor |
Dual 2.4GHz XEON processors 533 FSB |
Dual 2.4GHz XEON processors 533 FSB |
Dual 2.4GHz XEON processors 533 FSB |
| Memory |
Dual Channel 512MB Crucial DDR 266 |
Dual Channel 512MB Crucial DDR 266 |
Dual Channel 512MB Crucial DDR 266 |
| DVD Drive |
Toshiba DVD ROM |
Toshiba DVD-ROM |
Toshiba DVD-ROM |
| Hard Drive |
Maxtor 60GB 7200 RPM |
Maxtor 60GB 7200 RPM |
Maxtor 60GB 7200 RPM |
| Chipset |
Intel E7505 |
Intel E7505 |
Intel E7505 |
| Graphics |
ATI Radeon 9500 |
ATI Radeon 9500 |
ATI Radeon 9500 |
PC Mark 2002
For PC Mark 2002, we compared against the Abit
BG7E which uses the same 845 chipset and the MiniQ 450 which uses a SiS
chipset. As expected, the 845 systems were very similar in performance
though the SiS memory scores were slightly better. Higher numbers are
better.
Business Winstone 2002 and Multimedia Content
Creation 2003
The Business Winstone 2002 and Multimedia Content
Creation 2003 benchmarks were introduced when we started our dual processor
benchmarks. This is
the real reason why you see the Shuttle SB51G compared against these
dual processor boards. Of course, dual processor systems will crush the
single processor SB51G in these benchmarks. We will look into how a single
Hyper-Threading enabled Pentium 3.06GHz processor will perform against
a dual processor
system later on. These benchmarks reflect how well
a system
can handle multiple tasks concurrently. Higher numbers are better.
3D Mark 2001 SE
For this benchmark, we switched back to the Abit
BG7E and the SiS based MiniQ. The Shuttle board experienced higher scores
mostly due
to better Intel graphics drivers for the 845GE based system. Higher numbers
are better.
Cinebench 2003
We compared up against dual processor systems again
for this benchmark. It is interesting to note that the benchmarks that
do not utilize the
graphics card are actually very similar in scores. This is mostly
due to the fact that the benchmark does not truly utilize a multi processor
system (except for the last test which is not shown here). It goes
to show that for many graphics intensive applications such as rendering
and gaming apps,
you will not always benefit from having a dual processor systems. However
if you are peforming multiple tasks at the
same
time,
multiprocessor
systems
are
ideal due to the robust response of the OS. Lower
numbers are better.
POVRay 3.5
POVRay is a CPU intensive benchmark and not surprisingly,
the two 845 based systems performed nearly identically. Lower scores
are better.
SPECviewperf 7.1
This benchmark essentially compares a system that
utilized an ATI Radeon 9500 vs the performance of the on board Intel
Extreme Graphics core of
the SB51G system.Moral of the story? If you want gaming performance from
your SB51G? Add an AGP card to the mix. Higher numbers are better.
Microsoft HCT
We ran the Microsoft Hardware Compatibility Tests on the SB51G and the
stress tests completed successfully. The HCT is a good tool to see how
well a system performs when thousands of different system calls are made
to the OS and device drivers. Though not a completely all encompassing
test, it is still a good way to burn in a system.
|